Marcus Ball Contact Site Index
Systems & Conversation ] Authority & learning ] Bloom’s Taxonomy ] Imitation ] Learning & Teaching System ] The Learning Curve ] Learning how to Learn ] Situational Learning ] Resistance to Learning ] Tacit knowledge ]
Cultural Considerations ...

Cunningham on
Getting Real

An example of the
primacy of revealed
over scientific truth


Past Employment

Residential Property Management Community Manager PPA
Residential Property Management Assistant Manager, Leasing  HVA
Online Technical Account Manager
Massage Therapy Clinical Therapist
Telecom Products Sales Executive
ASP Support Client Services
Inquiry Center CRM Specialist
Call Center Design Engineer
Help Desk Desktop Support
Call Center Client Communications
Hospitality Reservations Manager
Sales Special Orders
Retail Commercial Ast Manager

Or Read:
Customer Centricity

Cultural Considerations

What counts as "learning" for educational purposes depends on cultural, social, economic and political factors, because implicit in education as a deliberate enterprise is the notion of prescription. Education is supposed to be a Good Thing. So having a phobia about worms is learned behavior, but it does not count as Education. Nor does acquiring greater skill in breaking into cars as a result of learning from peers in prison.

levels of analysis

The process starts with what the society considers to be desirable knowledge, and indeed what counts as knowledge at all: consider the ambivalence about astrology, or complementary medicine. The social structure is also reflected in the attitude to the knowledge — is it unquestioned truth, to be learned and reproduced but not modified, or is it provisional knowledge on which critical faculties can be trained? (As one sociologist said, "Newton stood on the shoulders of those who went before: sociologists stand on their heads!") This leads into culturally endorsed models of the learning process, and variable acceptance of the initiative of the learner — as seen in constructivism or andragogy.

The subject matter, framed by culture, imposes its own discipline: it may be linear (like math, in which you have to learn the concept of number, counting, addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, in that order, before you can go on to anything else) or accessible at any point. It may be governed by a clear philosophical structure (like science), or by its history (like law), or none of these. It may be convergent or divergent. See inter al. Kolb on this.

The society produces an educational system in its image, whether it makes use of informal — “situated” learning — or is seduced (as Illich would see it) by the Western model of dedicated educational institutions, whose inadequacies have been so clearly discussed in Becker’s wonderful essay.

Then that educational system imposes its own constraints on what can be taught and learned and what counts as learning, through its assessment and accreditation procedures. This in turn is filtered and interpreted by the teacher. The micro-culture of the learner's group or class may encourage, inhibit or distort various kinds of learning. Then there is the learner as a person, making continuous "cost-benefit decisions" (Claxton, 1996) about what it is worth learning, and endowed with certain aptitudes and preferences: until finally we reach the "learning bit" of that person.

Critical Approaches to Education

For a selection of different critical stances to the construction of knowledge and educational assumptions, start (!) with:

COLLINS M (1991) Adult Education as Vocation London: Routledge

DEWEY J (1938) Experience and Education New York: Macmillan

FREIRE P (1972) The Pedagogy of the Oppressed Harmondsworth: Penguin

ILLICH I (1970) De-Schooling Society Harmondsworth: Penguin

 and go on to Habermas and Marcuse

Original content updated and hosted at www.learningandteaching.info/learning/

Now visit www.BayAreaMasage.Net - - Marcus Ball ] Contact ] Site Index ]